Judge shot in ambush; attacker slain

This image made from video provided by WTOV-TV in Steubenville, Ohio, shows a police vehicle responding to the ambush-style shooting of a Jefferson County judge as he walked to the Jefferson County Courthouse.
This image made from video provided by WTOV-TV in Steubenville, Ohio, shows a police vehicle responding to the ambush-style shooting of a Jefferson County judge as he walked to the Jefferson County Courthouse.

COLUMBUS, Ohio -- An Ohio judge was shot Monday morning outside a courthouse in an ambush attack that ended when the judge and a probation officer returned fire, killing the attacker, authorities said.

Police said a man apparently waiting for Judge Joseph Bruzzese, who sits on the Jefferson County Court of Common Pleas, ran up to the judge and began shooting when Bruzzese approached the courthouse. Bruzzese drew a gun and fired at least five rounds at the shooter, possibly hitting the attacker, Jefferson County Sheriff Fred Abdalla told reporters Monday morning.

"This individual laid in wait for our judge," Abdalla said, tearing up during his remarks. "It just hurts. First thing on Monday morning, you have a judge shot in front of his courthouse. ... This was an ambush and an attempted murder on our judge.

"Whoever thought this could happen here?" Abdalla said.

The shooting occurred in Steubenville, Ohio, a place recently known for a high-profile rape case involving high school football players. The shooter was identified by authorities on Monday afternoon as Nathaniel "Nate" Richmond, 51, the father of one of the two teenage boys found delinquent -- or guilty -- in 2013 as part of that rape case.

Ma'Lik Richmond, then 17, served about 10 months in a youth lockup after being convicted with another Steubenville football player of raping a 16-year-old girl during an alcohol-fueled party in 2012.

The case drew international attention to the eastern Ohio city of 18,000 and led to allegations of a coverup to protect the football team.

Richmond, now 21, is currently on the Youngstown State football team but isn't allowed to play in any games, the school said earlier this month.

News of his participation drew a wave of criticism in the university community recently, and a petition was started to keep him from playing.

Jane Hanlin, prosecutor for Jefferson County, identified Nathaniel Richmond as the shooter and said authorities do not believe there was any connection between the shooting and Richmond's son.

Bruzzese had "nothing at all to do with that particular case," Hanlin said during an afternoon briefing, noting that it was handled by a judge from another area.

However, Hanlin said authorities still did not know what might have motivated Monday's shooting. She said Richmond did have a criminal history and was involved in a pending case, but it was unclear whether that case had anything to do with the shooting.

Bruzzese, 65, was talking after being wounded, Steubenville City Manager James Mavromatis told WTOV-TV. The judge was flown to a Pittsburgh-area hospital. Ohio Gov. John Kasich said he was told that Bruzzese would survive.

Richmond was struck three times. Because a probation officer as well as the judge fired rounds at him, Abdalla said it was not clear whether one of Bruzzese's bullets hit Richmond, who had fired five rounds at the judge.

During remarks to reporters Monday afternoon, Abdalla described Bruzzese as an avid hunter and sportsman. The sheriff said that years earlier, he had urged Bruzzese to carry a weapon with him for protection because of all of the "nutcases" around the country.

"With all the nuts running around, I encouraged him to get a weapon," Abdalla said. "And he did."

According to Abdalla, Richmond approached the courthouse early Monday morning in a car with another person before leaving and returning. When Richmond saw Bruzzese, Abdalla said, he "jumped out" of the car and ran over to begin shooting.

The second person in the car is not considered an accomplice, Abdalla said, and told authorities that the shooter had only said he had to be in court Monday morning. This second person, who was not identified, did not get out of the car and was wounded by a possible bullet ricochet and taken to a hospital, the sheriff said.

Abdalla said authorities have video of the shooting, which they are working to have enhanced to show people what happened.

"This man shoots a judge, could've killed him," Abdalla said of Richmond.

He added: "Thank God he's not that good a shot."

Abdalla said authorities were investigating whether Richmond had any connections to the judge, saying only that the shooter had "been involved in different things in Steubenville."

Bruzzese's work involves hearing criminal felonies as well as some civil cases, according to the court's website.

U.S. Rep. Bill Johnson, who represents Jefferson County, released a statement saying he was "very saddened and alarmed" by the shooting, noting that he had worked with Bruzzese, and he linked the incident to the attack on Republican members of Congress at a baseball practice in Virginia earlier this summer.

"From the shootings at the congressional baseball practice, to today's tragic shooting, public officials are increasingly under assault," Johnson said. "Public service shouldn't be a dangerous occupation, but it all too often is."

The chief justice of the Ohio Supreme Court called the attack a "cowardly ambush" and urged court personnel -- especially judges -- to take extra precautions.

The attack "reminds us all of the very real potential for violence against judges," Maureen O'Connor said. "Violence against judges represents an attack on the Rule of Law, the foundation of our country."

Information for this article was contributed by Mark Berman of The Washington Post and Andrew Welsh-Huggins of The Associated Press.

A Section on 08/22/2017

Upcoming Events