Reporter Lee Strobel was investigating the story of his life, and he knew it.
As legal affairs editor at the Chicago Tribune, he had covered plenty of hot-button issues -- like abortion rights -- that required him to wrestle with the views of people on the "other side." Strobel knew what he believed, as an atheist committed to abortion rights and other liberal causes. But he knew, as a journalist, that he had a job to do.
"I grew up in the era of old-school journalism, when you really had to try to be balanced and fair and accurate. You had to listen to what other people had to say," he said. "Besides, I knew that if I turned in a story with holes in it, my editor would come down on me. He'd bounce that thing right back."
But this story was different. The person on the other side of this Strobel investigation was his formerly agnostic wife, Leslie, whose 1979 conversion to Christianity rocked the foundations of their marriage. Suddenly, their home contained a new set of expectations when it came to anger, alcohol, ego and workaholism.
"I was mad and I wanted my wife back," Strobel said. "I decided that the Resurrection was the key to this whole thing and I set out to prove it was all nonsense."
The result was 19 months of research and interviews with experts on both sides of centuries of arguments about the claims of Christianity. As a graduate of the famous University of Missouri journalism program, and then of Yale Law School, Strobel worked through a library of classic texts by atheist and Christian scholars.
The result was Strobel's own conversion, a career shift into ministry and, in 1998, the first of his many books, The Case for Christ. This year, that book evolved into a movie built on a screenplay by Hollywood veteran Brian Bird -- a former reporter. The indie film made a modest $15 million at the box office. Here is the surprise: It drew an A-plus rating from CinemaScore, and 79 percent of Rotten Tomatoes critics' ratings were positive.
The key to many reviews was that journalism remained front and center in the story, creating what Variety film critic Joe Leydon called a cross between a basic "investigative-journalism drama" and a "theological detective story."
In a typical screen moment, the Strobel character asks a psychologist -- played by veteran Faye Dunaway -- if 500 witnesses who claimed to have seen the resurrected Jesus could have been having the same delusion at the same time. She replies: "That would have been an even bigger miracle than the Resurrection."
Watching events in his own life unfold onscreen, Strobel saw actor Mike Vogel, best known for his work in the sci-fi thriller Cloverfield, keep plugging away with his yellow reporter's notepad, asking question after question after question.
Yes, Strobel was in a tense, painful fight to save his marriage. Yet his old-school journalistic instincts and standards were involved as well. He wasn't hearing the simple answers that he wanted to hear, but he kept going.
"It would have been easy to have just pursued the arguments for my side of this debate," he said when reached at his home office in Houston. He serves as professor of Christian thought at Houston Baptist University and as a teaching pastor at the giant Woodlands Church. "That would have been a pretty quick investigation, if I had only been willing to talk to people who agreed with me. That's pretty easy work, when you've already decided what you believe and you refuse to listen to anyone who isn't on your side of the argument. ... But what kind of journalism is that?"
That's a relevant question, in an age when journalists and activists on the left and the right are bemoaning the rise of "fake news," while many keep setting the professional bar extra low when it comes to anonymous sources and one-sided reporting.
Strobel said he doesn't think journalists "can be totally objective, but we can set high standards for what we do, in terms of being accurate, fair and balanced. ... We have to believe that journalists can play some role in this republic of ours, other than helping people throw mud at each other."
Terry Mattingly is the editor of GetReligion.org and Senior Fellow for Media and Religion at The King's College in New York. He lives in Oak Ridge, Tenn.
Religion on 06/17/2017