Today's Paper Latest Coronavirus Cooking Families Core values Listen Story ideas iPad Weather Newsletters Obits Puzzles Archive
story.lead_photo.caption One of two rock sepulchers containing the bones of victims of the Mountain Meadows Massacre sits in a field in southern Utah. The other is about 1,000 feet away.

HARRISON -- Two mass-grave sites for victims of the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre have been located in southern Utah, an archaeologist said.

Photo by Arkansas Democrat-Gazette
Map and key events in the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre.
Photo by Bill Bowden
J.K. Fancher, a distant relative of Alexander Fancher, speaks Saturday in Harrison at an event marking the anniversary of the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre.

Everett Bassett said he found the rock tombs by using U.S. Army records from 1859 and locating the California/Old Spanish Trail.

Bassett said he was sitting on a pile of boulders when he realized that the rocks were the top layer of a tumulus, an archaeological term for a burial chamber or sepulcher.

"It was like getting hit in the stomach," he said.

Bassett presented his report Saturday night at a meeting in Harrison of the Mountain Meadows Monument Foundation.

"The graves are huge," Bassett told about 100 people at the Quality Inn Convention Center. "The men's grave is 35 feet across."

Bassett said afterward that the site includes an apron of riprap around the men's tumulus, which is in a ravine. The women and children's sepulcher has no such apron, he said. The two sepulchers are the same size -- 8 feet wide, 12 feet long and about 4 feet high, and they're oriented in the same east-west direction, he said.

Bassett of Forest Knolls, Calif., is a senior biologist for Transcon Environmental Inc., a firm that does environmental analysis. Bassett, who has 30 years of experience in historical archaeology, said he took a personal interest in the Mountain Meadows Massacre and did the research on his own to locate the burial sites.

About 120 people died in the massacre as their wagon train traveled from Arkansas to California. Most of the victims were from north Arkansas -- in what would now be Boone, Carroll, Crawford, Johnson and Marion counties. They were killed by Mormon militiamen and American Indians.

The massacre site, 33 miles north of St. George, Utah, was declared a national historical landmark in 2011. While the site of the initial attack has been accurately marked, the burial sites of most of the victims haven't, Bassett said.

Bassett said he visited the Mountain Meadows historical site in the summer of 2014 and realized that monuments for the two main grave sites were in the wrong places. That's when he began researching the Army records and the location of the California/Old Spanish Trail.

Bassett said a monument for the male victims is 2,196 feet from their sepulcher, and a monument for the women and children's tomb is about 1,000 feet from their burial site. The two groups were massacred at different locations at Mountain Meadows and buried in sepulchers about 1,000 feet apart, he said.

"I think people will be glad to know where these graves are," Bassett said in an interview before his presentation. "I think people like to know where their relatives are buried. Knowing where the bodies are helps people to grieve."

Monuments that now mark the wrong burial sites are on property owned by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. But the actual burial sites are on private property, Bassett said.

"None of these graves are in the area set aside for the national monument," Bassett told the crowd Saturday.

Ben Pykles, a historic sites coordinator for the Mormon Church, attended the event Saturday in Harrison and said he hasn't had a chance to read Bassett's report.

"I'm interested," said Pykles, who has a doctorate in historical archaeology. "I'm looking forward to looking into it further. Because of our involvement in the site, we're clearly interested."

Some of the victims are buried at the site of the initial attack, where a modern monument was built in 1990 to replace more rustic cairns that had marked the location since the massacre.

The Baker-Fancher wagon train was attacked while the travelers were camped at Mountain Meadows, a staging point before crossing deserts on the way to California. The settlers on the wagon train held off the attackers for five days.

Then, on Sept. 11, 1857, Maj. John D. Lee approached the wagon train, offering safe passage to Cedar City if the travelers would lay down their weapons. They did and were then executed after being marched away from the battle site. Only 17 children under age 8 were spared.

Lee was tried and convicted in the massacre. He was executed by firing squad at Mountain Meadows on March 23, 1877.

Lee's trial was reported widely by 19th century newspapers. Lee said he was merely following orders from militia leaders.

Exactly why the wagon train was attacked and the people massacred has been debated over the past 158 years.

Some historians cite hostilities between Mormons and the federal government, saying the wagon train just happened to pass through Utah at a volatile time.

Others cite the murder of Parley Pratt in Arkansas on May 13, 1857. Pratt was a Mormon apostle and is the great-great-grandfather of former GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney.

The massacre victims were initially buried in shallow graves, but erosion and animals soon exposed the remains.

The trail was the Interstate 40 of its day, with wagon trains passing through on the way to California. Bassett said having the skeletal remains of a massacre along the California/Old Spanish Trail was an embarrassment for the federal government.

So 20 months after the massacre, the U.S. Army sent 207 soldiers to collect and bury the bones, which by that time were mostly fragments. According to the Army's description, the tombs are basically ossuaries, containing piles of human bones rather than skeletons of individuals, Bassett said.

The sepulchers haven't been excavated.

Bassett said he doesn't know if the bones are in the tombs or are underneath them. He said the bones could have been placed on top of a layer of boulders, then covered with another layer of rocks.

"Soldiers collected hundreds of bones and put them in here," Bassett said, referring to the sepulchers. "I don't know how many bones are under them, but we do know these are the grave sites."

Bassett said the sepulchers are within 5 feet of the locations described in Army records from 1859. He said earlier researchers may have missed the tombs because they were mistaken about the location of the California/Old Spanish Trail.

"I figured out where the road was," he said. "Then I went back and started going through the historic records. It took 20 minutes to find them."

Bassett said he's surprised that the burial sites weren't discovered before now because the Army records are very accurate. The burial site for the women and children is within sight of Utah Highway 18, he said.

"Truckers were driving by honking at me," Bassett said. "The location where the women and children were massacred is right in the middle of the highway, to some extent."

The monuments and markers for the burial sites are vague on exactly where the victims are buried.

"Now, instead of saying it happened out there somewhere, we'll be able to say it happened right here," Bassett said.

Bassett said the burial sites don't look like what people would expect. Because the tomb for the men is in a ravine, it's difficult to see from above ground, he said.

"When you look at it from above, it looks like a farmer was dumping rocks in a ravine," Bassett said. But the sites are "carefully engineered," he said. Basalt and granite rocks were used instead of sandstone, which is considered of lower quality, said Bassett.

"It becomes immediately obvious when you look at these that they're not just the result of land clearing," said Scott Fancher, a Harrison lawyer who is a "collateral descendant" of Alexander Fancher, one of the wagon train's leaders.

Fancher said Bassett's find is a "big deal."

"I think a lot of the story is going to be 'What's next?' And that frankly remains to be seen," Fancher said.

Shannon Novak, a bioarchaeologist from Syracuse University who specializes in trauma and mass death, said the stone structures Bassett found do appear to be grave sites.

Novak, who attended the meeting Saturday in Harrison, said the remains of 28 people are buried in a cairn at the battle site.

"So when you think about that, there are still approximately 100 individuals unaccounted for," she said. "So the vast majority of the people who were murdered are probably in these cairns. They were meant more as graves, to keep the wolves out and the bodies in."

Novak examined bones of some of the victims that were inadvertently unearthed at the battle site. She's the author of a book titled House of Mourning: A Biocultural History of the Mountain Meadows Massacre.

Bassett said he's confident that he has found the grave sites.

"I'm thinking that I might be wrong, but I'm probably not," Bassett told the crowd Saturday.

Bassett said he expects his peers to begin research on his findings to prove him either right or wrong.

"I guess the question now is what do you want to do about it?" Bassett asked the crowd.

"I know it's stressful not knowing where your ancestors are buried," he said. "Maybe if we can put this to rest by knowing where they are, it might create a balm to heal some of these wounds."

SundayMonday on 09/13/2015

Print Headline: Resting places of victims in 1857 massacre found


Sponsor Content

Archived Comments

  • cliffcarson
    September 13, 2015 at 9 a.m.

    "So the vast majority of the people who were murdered are probably in these cairns. They were meant more as graves, to keep the wolves out and the bodies in."
    Keep the Wolves out? The burial of the massacre victims occurred about two years after the massacre and the burial was done by U S Soldiers who picked up the bones that were scattered along the massacre site after the Mormons executed those who had entrusted their lives to the Mormon Militia.

  • JakeTidmore
    September 13, 2015 at 2:30 p.m.

    Good point Cliff.

  • cliffcarson
    September 13, 2015 at 3:43 p.m.

    I thought you might be interested - I have copied two excerpts from a lengthy account about the massacre. Google "Children of the Massacre"
    From the St. Louis Post Dispatch, July 1893
    Mormon bishop John D. Lee, who wrote his confession under sentence of death, tell the sickening story. It was about daylight Friday morning, the fifth day of the siege, when a council was held by the Mormons taking part in the fight decided that the emigrants must be decoyed out of their camp and then murdered. Lee says about the massacre:
    "Dan McFarland rode before the women and led them right up to the troops, where they still stood in open order as I had left them. The women and larger children were walking ahead as directed, and the men following them. The foremost man was about fifty yards behind the hindmost woman. The women and children were hurried right up to the troops. When the men came up they cheered the soldiers as if they believed the militia were acting honestly. Higbee then gave the order for his men to form in single file and take their places as arranged, that is, at the right of the emigrants. I saw this much, but about this time our wagons passed out of sight of the troops over the hill. I had disobeyed orders in part by turning off as I did, for I was anxious to be out of sight of the bloody deed that I knew was to follow. I knew that I had much to do yet that was cruel and unnatural. It was my duty with the two drivers to kill the sick and wounded who were in the wagons, when we heard the guns of the troops fire. I was walking between the wagons, the horses were going in a fast walk, and we were fully half a mile from Maj. Higbee and his men, when we heard the firing. As we heard the guns I ordered a halt and we proceeded to do our part. * * *
    "While going back to the brethren I passed the bodies of several women. In one place I saw six or seven bodies together. They were stripped perfectly naked, the Indians having torn off the clothes. I walked along the line where the emigrants had been killed and saw many bodies on the field, all naked. I saw ten children near together. They were from 10 to 16 years of age. * * * I do not know how many were killed, but I thought then that there were some fifteen women, about ten children, and about forty men, but the statement of others I have since talked with about the massacre makes me think there were fully 101.

  • JakeTidmore
    September 13, 2015 at 4:24 p.m.

    It sounds so much like the Sonderkommando squads that rounded up East European Jews and massacred/executed them. (Shudder!!)

  • FreeSpiritMan
    September 13, 2015 at 7:06 p.m.

    Was the Mormon Militia the forerunner of the "Oath-keepers" ?

  • cliffcarson
    September 13, 2015 at 8:12 p.m.

    The Mormons claimed they were doing "Gods" work by massacring the Wagon Train people because they , the U S Government , was opposed to allowing a "Religious" State ( Utah) into the Union as a Religious State for Mormons. The Government had an Army on the way to Utah to subdue the insurrection when the massacre took place. The Republicans are all for allowing "Armed Oath Keepers" to run around like Vigilantes. If this is not stopped and soon it is inevitable that a situation will arise where "Oath Keepers" will kill some people and a real crisis will be fueled.
    Be careful how you vote. You should be seeing now what you are going to have if you keep voting for Republican candidates.

  • DontDrinkDatKoolAid
    September 13, 2015 at 9:43 p.m.

    Shame upon the ones that make this a political issue of today.

  • Kharma
    September 13, 2015 at 11:25 p.m.

    This massacre, and thousands of other examples of atrocities committed or justified by the adherents of various religious superstitions over the centuries, are proof positive that religion needs to be kept as far away from government and its policies as is possible.

    Can't think of any examples? Try 9/11, the Salem witch trials, the Crusades, the Inquisition, and slavery for starters.

  • DontDrinkDatKoolAid
    September 13, 2015 at 11:55 p.m.

    Well Kharma, have any numbers (of the murdered) to support your Statement? Ball park numbers will acceptable.

  • Kharma
    September 14, 2015 at 7:20 a.m.

    ddka: You apparently got through whatever schooling you attended without taking history classes to not have heard of any of the foregoing examples. Absolutely amazing. Since you apparently lack a substantive history education here are a few more examples: the Mumbai train bombings, the "troubles" in Northern Ireland, and the Massacre at Béziers in 1209 from whence the saying "Kill them all for God shall know his own" and its iterations flow. You do your own "numbers " research, it sounds as if you are sorely in need of edification as to the evils of religious fanaticism.