Today's Paper Search Latest stories Traffic #Gazette200 Drivetime Mahatma Digital Replica FAQs Weather Newsletters Most commented Obits Puzzles + Games Archive

Over the weekend we lit the first candle, for Sunday was the first night of this minor eight-day Jewish holiday that's become a major one in our time. Maybe because of its proximity to Christmas and the temptation to provide some sort of Jewish equivalent.

Once again we repeated the age-old but ever-new blessings. Songs were sung, latkes eaten, and children's games played with a spinning top. But what does Chanukah celebrate?

Answer: A successful Jewish revolt against a Syrian empire ruled by the Seleucid dynasty of Greek kings more than 2,000 years ago.

Well, not exactly. The revolt was not so much against the Syrian emperor Antiochus Epiphanes (Antiochus the Divine!) as against his attempt to impose Hellenistic culture on ancient Judaea and suppress its own.

Well, not exactly. It's not noised about, but this now-celebrated revolt against the Syrians was really something of a civil war between those Jews who proposed to adopt more of the then-fashionable Greek culture and those who rejected it. The rebels viewed its games and gods as a desecration and fought for the old ways, the ancient practices and beliefs.

It may not be the politically correct thing to say, but this religious festival commemorates a military victory of fundamentalism over modernism, tradition over assimilation, of the old ways over new and supposedly advanced ideas.

Well, not exactly. The military aspects of the struggle are scarcely mentioned in today's celebration of Chanukah. The focus has shifted over the centuries. The very name Chanukah, or Dedication, now refers to the cleansing of the Temple in Jerusalem after it was defiled by pagan rites.

Over the centuries of exile, the rabbis succeeded in de-emphasizing the military aspects of the holiday--which were much too violent, too chauvinistic and too provocative for their tastes. After all, the holiday isn't named for any particular battle or campaign or hero. It isn't the Feast of the Maccabees, who led the revolt. Therefore the real theme of Chanukah is the rededication of the Temple in Jerusalem.

Well, not exactly. The essential ritual of the holiday has become the blessing over the Chanukah lights, usually a home ceremony. A talmudic legend tells how the liberators of the Temple found only enough consecrated oil to burn for one day, but it lasted for eight--enough time to prepare a new supply. Which is why we celebrate the holiday for eight days.

We're really celebrating not the redemption of the ancient Temple but the miracle of the lights that took place there. In the glow of the candles, the heroic feats of the Maccabees have become transmuted into acts of divine intervention.

The blessing over the candles recited each night of the holiday goes: "Blessed art Thou, O Lord our God, King of the universe, who wrought miracles for our fathers in days of old." Miracles, not victories. We celebrate His gracious providence, not our military prowess.

At Passover, the story of the Exodus from Egypt is told with the same moral attached: It is He who delivered us from bondage, not we who freed ourselves. Freedom is a gift of God, not men.

The story of Chanukah doesn't merit inclusion in the Hebrew Bible, aka the Old Testament. This swashbuckling saga of heroic deeds in battle has been relegated to the Apocrypha. A mere military victory rates only a secondary place in the canon. The victory is celebrated not for its own sake but for what it reveals of the Divine.

So a messy little guerrilla war in the dim past of a forgotten empire has become something else, something that partakes of the Eternal. The central metaphor of all religious belief--light--reduces the imperial intrigue and internecine warfare of those tumultuous times to shadowy details. And that may be the greatest miracle of Chanukah: the transformation of the oldest and darkest of human activities, war, into a feast of illumination.

There is more than a single theme to this minor but never simple holiday. One can almost trace the ebbs and flows of Jewish history, its yearnings and fulfillments, its wisdom and folly, its holiness and vainglory, by noting which themes of Chanukah have been emphasized when in Jewish history.

History may say a good deal more about the time in which it is written than the time it describes. The message of Chanukah changes from age to age because the past we choose to remember is a reflection of the present and what it values. When Chanukah is celebrated with pride, a fall is sure to follow. When it inspires humility, we may yet be redeemed.

If there is one, unchanging message associated with this holiday whose significance changes with the changing times, it can be found in the portion of the Prophets designated to be read for the sabbath of Chanukah. It is Zechariah 4:1-7, with its penultimate verse: Not by might, nor by power, but by My spirit, saith the Lord of Hosts.



Paul Greenberg, the Pulitzer Prize-winning editorial writer and columnist for the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, is retired. Versions of this column have appeared to celebrate Chanukah in years past.

Editorial on 12/05/2018

Print Headline: The blessing of Chanukah


Sponsor Content

You must be signed in to post comments


  • WhododueDiligence
    December 5, 2018 at 8:11 a.m.

    Very good, sir. Peace.

  • Foghorn
    December 5, 2018 at 9:59 a.m.

    “the transformation of the oldest and darkest of human activities, war, into a feast of illumination“ is not a ‘miracle.’ It’s hypocrisy, pure and simple and breathtaking in its scope. Just like the systematic slaughter of Palestinians and theft of all that belongs to them is not being called what it is: genocide.

  • mrcharles
    December 5, 2018 at 11:02 a.m.

    "Though regarded as apocryphal by PG's people, the papist have accepted them there two books of ancient books to be contained in other ancient books. Hocus pocus.

    Very interesting history and like tales of knights , contains intrigue and heroics of people like those of poland, in the middle of great powers that usually cause them grief. I would suggest the reading as worthy of the time it takes to read them.

    Foghorn, we are just killer chimpanzees, with thumbs that cause us to create weapons of peace for defense except when we kill others with them. Those people have a history of killing each other's children over relics, sand, caves, who is the messiah [ pretty sure it is not pots and pans-read your bible], the best child of Abraham and sarah {great fleetwood mac song} [perhaps incest caused genetic defects in their descendants?]

    Also for those not of the scholarly type, the name of these warrior/priest was not maccabees. and the circumcision issues were very strange.

    PG, would love to hear a rendition of the Passion of the Anointed One from one who is not of that persuasion.

  • PopMom
    December 5, 2018 at 11:50 a.m.


    This column mentioned nothing about the Palestinian situation. Many Jews in this country do not support the current regime in Israel and its treatment of the Palestinians. There is a very active organization called J Street. Let's not blame all Jews across the world for the actions of a few in Israel. Characterizing all people based upon religion or ethnicity is just wrong. (I also do not have any problem getting into the faces of Jews who make bigoted remarks about Muslims.)

  • DontDrinkDatKoolAid
    December 6, 2018 at 1:12 a.m.

    But CommunistMom said nothing about Muslims killing Jews ... or their Jehad's. That's ok, I understand.