Today's Paper Latest stories Most commented Obits Traffic Weather Newsletters Puzzles + Games

"The central conservative truth is that it is culture, not politics, that determines the success of a society. The central liberal truth is that politics can change a culture and save it from itself."--the late U.S. Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan of New York.

It stands to reason, then, that politics also can damage or even ruin the more important culture.

It could do that by defining our culture's deviancy downward, to borrow and adapt another Moynihan phrase.

"Defining deviancy down" applies to the old philosophical concept that a society can abide only so much bad behavior, and at some point, absent reform, will cope by redefining bad behavior more tolerantly.

The Republican quest to normalize a president who is plainly a narcissistic megalomaniac and who lies, bullies, boasts, bloviates, calls names and posts on Twitter in the style and substance of a juvenile twit--that's defining politics downward.

It, in turn, damages our entire culture by this very simple process: Donald Trump's behavior--which includes attacking the storied American journalistic institution when it reports on him in accurate but wounding ways--influences the political party newly dependent on him to lower its standard of acceptable behavior.

That party lowers that standard to the point of brazen contradiction of what it supposedly stood for--the notion that character matters--as recently as when character-flawed Bill Clinton of the other party famously misbehaved.

So now, when a book comes out presuming to expose Trump for the incompetent horror that he is, leading journalists admit that, yes, the author, Michael Wolff, has a reputation for error, embellishment and loose approximations of quotations. But they say the book rings true based on what they've been told off the record and observed if merely by reading Twitter. They say it offers a cosmic and vital truth and therefore should be read and considered on what amounts to a relaxed standard of credibility.

Do you see how that works? Trump's behavior in the political arena is steadily spreading cancerously into the culture, defining acceptability downward, to the point that Republicans stand for less than before and journalists make allowances for sins they once would have assailed righteously.

Am I blaming Trump's personal behavior and its tragic pre-eminence in our politics for a decline in what journalists will accept?

Why, yes, I am.

More than that, I'm blaming Trump for a spreading debasement throughout our culture. That is why I embrace the spirit of that column by conservative Bret Stephens in the New York Times.

He wrote that Trump's personal failings are more inevitably harmful to the culture than the conservative policies that Stephens supports are healthful for the country.

Ideally, he'd like both--fine conservative policies under an exemplary president elevating our culture. But, forced to choose, he values an exemplary leader over policies he agrees with.

Perhaps he calculates, as I do, that cultural erosion is direr than a repeal of the Obamacare individual mandate is transformational. The next president could well restore that mandate to policy. His or her harder challenge would be raising plummeted cultural standards.

The essential challenge would be to MAGA--make America good again.

You don't do that with a signature on an executive order. You do it with consistent and evident personal decency, by making that little light of yours shine.

This is a bipartisan matter, of course. Bill Clinton's behavior in political office--the sex with an intern and the lying about it to our faces and in a sworn statement--caused some of my liberal friends to tell me that perjury is commonplace and not such a big deal. Nearly every divorce case entails a false statement under oath, they said.

That's a clear example of the logical inverse of Moynihan's premise. It shows politics seeping influentially into the broader and more important culture and lowering standards to the point of pooh-poohing lying.

We rallied from that with eight years of a decent if incompetent president in George W. Bush and eight years after that of both an honorable and competent president in Barack Obama.

What I seek to describe is a country that desperately needs as its next president ... oh, maybe Joe Biden, even at that age, or John Kasich, even with those social-issue views, or any of the millions of American women who are saner and more honorable than the unfolding American tragedy with which we're burdened.

I'd take Susan Collins right now, ponderous though she be.

Oprah? Let's take a long look. The recent experience with media celebrity has been disastrous.

Maybe, from the influence of one of those--and in a culture influenced by their behavior--we'd get tell-all books that wouldn't have much to tell and would tell it with attributed quotations and footnotes.

The new presidential campaign should be about the person, stupid.


John Brummett, whose column appears regularly in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, was inducted into the Arkansas Writers' Hall of Fame in 2014. Email him at Read his @johnbrummett Twitter feed.

Editorial on 01/09/2018

Print Headline: A ruined culture

Sponsor Content


You must be signed in to post comments
  • RobertBolt
    January 9, 2018 at 7:29 a.m.

    Time for someone to write that Brummett hit the nail on the head and will surely aggravate the right, so the people on the right can call Brummett names, so all the trolls on both sides can predictably begin trashing each other personally, continuing their endless mission to poison discourse and to embarrass the state. Woo-hoo!

  • TimberTopper
    January 9, 2018 at 8:33 a.m.

    Another on the spot effort, John. As I'm sure you already know, the haters will be here.

  • mozarky2
    January 9, 2018 at 8:44 a.m.

    CNN reporting that Trump’s holding his hand over his heart during the National Anthem last night is a sure sign of impending heart failure, and the 25th Amendment must be invoked to save the country, or something.

  • TimberTopper
    January 9, 2018 at 9:26 a.m.

    moz the only thing I've seen is, someone questioning whether he knew the words to the National Anthem. Surely, they must be joking about that, as is the heart failure thing regarding his hand over his heart.

  • Rightside
    January 9, 2018 at 9:35 a.m.

    The media and democrat smear campaign never ends. It's been 40 years with the democrat media demonize campaign aganist republican presidents.
    The media push now is the President is stupid and is mentally unbalanced. Promoted by a political party that counts among its prized representatives one Maxine Waters. New York Times, Washington Post, CNN and CBS and ABC and NBC and NPR and the small town columnists sing to demonize the president night-and-day. Ford was stupid, Bush was dumb, Trump is unblanced and dumb. As someone once said "Liberals can't give traditionalist views a fair hearing, it threatens their ideology."
    In 1993, the Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan applied his slogan to the “moral deregulation” that had eroded families and increased crime.
    Columnist Charles Krauthammer expanded Moynihan’s point by proposing the reverse — that not only were we “normalizing what was once considered deviant,” but we were also “finding deviant what was once considered normal.” Think date rape, political correctness and politically incorrect speech. In time, the inevitable lower standards and moral relativism brought us the movies, TV shows, fashions, sex norms and web pages we have today. Deviant and normal swapped places.

    Low-income and working-class families are enjoying significant economic gains not experienced in nearly 20 years. Consumers, businesses and investors are more confident than at any time under Obama. Majority of Americans say the U.S. economy is running strong, and most believe the upward trend will continue under President Trump. Media, Dems can't stand progress, the smear campaign shall comtinue.

  • PopMom
    January 9, 2018 at 9:44 a.m.

    Another good Brummett column. As far as Oprah, she would be better than what we've got. I am not against celebrities or business people running for office, but I favor candidates who have served in Congress, as Governor, or at least as a big city mayor. Government is different than business. The Democrats need to win back the presidency to limit the damage done to the judiciary by many of the Republican appointments. All the Democrats have to do is offer a decent moderate with experience who can connect with the American people. I have been touting Martin O'Malley and Amy Klobachar, but another Democrat made me aware of another potential strong Democratic candidate: Gov. Steve Bullock of Montana. Bullock is one of the most popular governors in the country, and he is interested in running for president. A Bullock and Klobachar ticket could be extremely popular. Sorry Cuomo, but Americans are sick of New Yorkers and their Goldman Sachs ties. I am more than sick of reality TV stars and the extreme wealthy. Let's just have some good common folk with experience in government for a refreshing change.

  • mozarky2
    January 9, 2018 at 10:28 a.m.

    TT, you "progs" are certainly a humorless bunch. I guess you just don't get my keen insight OR my rapier-sharp wit.
    Your loss.

    January 9, 2018 at 10:28 a.m.

    It's obvious Trump had no clue last night regarding the lyrics to the National Anthem. It was just another embarrassing fail for Cheetolini.

  • GeneralMac
    January 9, 2018 at 10:31 a.m.

    Interesting ( but expected) that PopMom considers any conservative judges appointed as..........." damage done to the judiciary"

  • GeneralMac
    January 9, 2018 at 10:36 a.m.

    NBC tweet saying............."the next president of the United States"

    And then you liberal posters ridicule Trump's assertion that the media is biased ?