Today's Paper Search Latest New app In the news Traffic #Gazette200 Drivetime Mahatma Listen Digital replica FAQ Weather Newsletters Obits Puzzles + Games Archive
story.lead_photo.caption Ballots are recounted by hand at the Benton County Election Commission office in Rogers.

ROGERS -- Benton County election officials failed to count almost 900 votes Tuesday night because of an overlooked thumb drive.

Kim Dennison with the Benton County Election Commission said no election outcomes were affected by the missing votes, which were from the Centro Cristiano de Rogers location on First Street.

The thumb drive was found Wednesday at the bottom of a bag carried in from the vote center location Tuesday night. In all, 897 votes were missed.

"It simply got overlooked," Dennison said Thursday.

Russell Anzalone, chairman of the Election Commission, stressed Thursday that the results provided Tuesday night were unofficial.

"We try to do everything possible to make sure every vote is counted," Anzalone said. "Sometimes, you don't catch everything. Something fell through the cracks, yes it did."

Dennison took the election tape, a printout of all votes cast at the location, and manually added the numbers to see if any races changed.

Dennison said Christie Craig, a Democrat running for the Arkansas House District 96 seat held by Rep. Grant Hodges, was looking at precinct by precinct numbers on the state election website and noticed that the numbers from that area of Rogers seemed low. Craig contacted the Election Commission.

Hodges beat Craig by 5,349 votes (68 percent) to Craig's 2,496 votes (32 percent). Craig picked up 334 votes at the missed site, and Hodges got 252 votes.

Craig said she studied the area in the leadup to the election because she lives about 2 miles from Centro Cristiano, which is her precinct. On Election Day, the turnout seemed low to her and that's when she started to look at the state website.

"These are my neighbors," she said Thursday. "I knew this wasn't going to flip the election, but it was important that all the votes be counted."

[2018 ELECTION: Full Democrat-Gazette coverage of Arkansas races]

In the Ward 1, Position 1 Rogers City Council race, Mandy McDonald Brashear added 292 votes cast for her. She had 6,519 votes (47 percent). Shawn Wright had 155 votes at that site. He was in second place with 2,855 votes (21 percent). Clint Hopper had 76 votes cast for him, and Rick Stocker got 66 at that location. Hopper was third, and Stocker was fourth in Tuesday's voting.

Nothing can be done with the thumb drive until 4 p.m. today when the Election Commission meets in Rogers. Preliminary and unofficial votes will then be amended, Dennison said. Also, provisional ballots will be counted today. The Election Commission is still waiting for overseas military ballots to arrive, Dennison said.

"It will all sort out at the end," Anzalone said.

In Benton County, 76,862 people, or 48 percent of the county's registered voters, voted in Tuesday's midterm election. Election results will be certified next Friday.

Metro on 11/09/2018

Print Headline: 897 uncounted votes in Northwest Arkansas discovered on lost thumb drive


Sponsor Content

You must be signed in to post comments


  • Dontcallmenames
    November 9, 2018 at 12:31 p.m.

    And every vote was for the Democrat, I'm sure. Funny how "lost votes" never turn up to bring a Republican for the win. I'm sure Democrats would graciously accept defeat too, should that occur.

    November 9, 2018 at 2:23 p.m.

    Strange how so many votes get lost and some mysteriously show up. Does this have anything to do with aything?? Is this another Jimmy Crow at work? Crap like this, There is no excuse for, None, Did Crap like this put the Cheeto Man in the White Room??

  • Modad3
    November 9, 2018 at 5:24 p.m.

    There is a thumbdrive that comes from each Vote Center vote counting machine. Depending on how many vote centers are in the county it is easy to get in a rush and distribute "unofficial" results that did not include one Vote Center tally. This is caught as you do the "checks and balances" to confirm the total. This is not suspicious if you understand how the tablet/voting machine/vote counter work that many Arkansas counties used this election.