Today's Paper Search Latest stories Listen Drivetime Mahatma Traffic Weather Newsletters Most commented Obits Puzzles + Games Archive

As a 39-year career social studies teacher in the Little Rock School District, I teach about government and its symbols. Our flags are important symbols of our republic and states, and each contains other symbols to represent them. As I look at the racially and spiritually diverse students in my school and members of my extended family, I must use multiple perspectives in teaching concepts that are controversial.

Last school year as I was explaining the symbols on the Arkansas flag, I looked at the faces of my elementary students ... a true representation of Little Rock's rainbow of racial diversity. When I got to the lone blue star above the name Arkansas, I looked at them and said, "I don't want to teach you about that star because it represents something bad in our state's history." Being inquisitive kids, they wanted to know what was the bad thing.

It hurts my heart to tell them that Arkansas was one of the states where slavery was legal and became part of the Confederate States of America. For many, it was the first time they had heard this. Young students prefer to think positively. It's why so many little kids love superheroes ... to save them from the bad. I told my elementary students that I was going to try to get the meaning of the fourth star changed.

Don't we want to represent the best of Arkansas? Our first flag was created in 1913 without that star. It was added during the years of Jim Crow to remind a portion of our population of a time when they were not equal. Today it is still a reminder of institutional racism.

I think if we want to keep the four large blue stars and not change the flag design, then we must change the meaning of at least one or more stars. Remove the Confederacy and add indigenous American groups who lived on Arkansas land before even the Spanish and French claimed it, the Quapaw, Caddo, and Osage. The Quapaw gave our state its name, the "downstream people."

We could also recognize the Five Civilized Tribes from the southeast U.S. who tried to live with the white culture and farm. Following the Indian Removal Act of 1830, these peoples were forced to leave their lands, their farms, their homes to travel to Oklahoma Indian Territory. Several routes were traveled in all kinds of weather across Arkansas. For one quarter of the Cherokee, Choctaw, Chickasaw, Creek, and Seminole, the horrific journey was a death march called The Trail of Tears.

The fourth star could represent the indigenous groups of early Arkansas with its five points paying homage to the Five Civilized Tribes. The late Arkansas historian Dr. C. Fred Williams taught us that not all of these displaced people made it to the crossing of the Arkansas River. Many hid in the hills and forests of Crowley's Ridge, so many Arkansans have this heritage.

There is also language on the flag's information sheet that recognizes Arkansas and Michigan as "sister" states. According to the Missouri Compromise of 1820 (created to keep the balance of power), if a slave state were to be added to the U.S., then a free state must also be added.

Arkansas (a slave state) was added in 1836 as the 25th state, and Michigan (a free state) was added in 1837 as the 26th state ... hence, another echo of our racist history. I know that I'm not the only one to notice that our flag's white stars inside blue bars that form the outline of the large diamond resembles another infamous flag from history.

If we remove the meaning of each of the four blue stars, then why have these symbols on the flag at all? Perhaps it is time to move our flag into the 21st century with a design that reflects who we are as a state today, without the taint of hidden bias.


Vicki Gonterman, M. Ed., of North Little Rock was the 2016 National Elementary Social Studies Teacher of the Year, presented by the National Council For the Social Studies.

Editorial on 04/11/2019

Print Headline: Hidden bias


Sponsor Content

You must be signed in to post comments


  • Skeptic1
    April 11, 2019 at 8:43 a.m.

    You need to start collecting on that 17 billion dollar retirement fund your union is sitting on. But maybe first you should take a refresher course in history and civics yourself. The first things fascist regimes due is rewrite history, remove historical statues, and ban and burn books that don't conform to "group think." Ever hear of the quote, "Those that refuse to learn from history are doomed to repeat it?" Next get a copy of Orwell's "1984," and pay special attention to the "Ministry of Truth," the resemblance to today's left media is terrifying, but I doubt you'll get it, you are too drunk on the liberal Kool-Aid. You are yet another reason for school vouchers parent can use for charter and private schools.

  • RBear
    April 11, 2019 at 6:34 p.m.

    skeptic YOU are the one who chooses to rewrite history. You are yet another reason we need teachers like Ms. Gonterman who has provided an ACCURATE understanding of the issues surrounding the flag. If you'll notice (which I sometimes wonder if you're even capable of), not once did she REWRITE history. The history will be taught at the appropriate time AND it will be noted that Arkansas did EXACTLY what she said.
    Tell me ONE THING she said that wasn't true. Not once in your ad hominem attack did you refute her statement, but chose to rant about some drivel regarding Orwell and facism (which you really don't understand). Go back and refute her statement regarding the Civil War and Arkansas' role. Provide some bit of counter or just STFU and crawl back in your basement.

  • 0boxerssuddenlinknet
    April 12, 2019 at 3:59 p.m.

    well, no wonder 64 percent of eighth graders are illiterate when you have their "teachers " more interested in indocternation than instructing children how to read, speak clearly and stand up tall.I am saddened that Vicki didn't explain to her class how our close to a million soldiers died in a war that ended slavery in our country but is still going on in the rest of the world.Vicki missed a golden opportunity to really teach her kids. shame on her.

  • GeneralMac
    April 12, 2019 at 4:43 p.m.

    I will use Vicki's editorial as the best arguement NOT top have the bible taught in school.

    Would you want someone like Vicki teaching HER interpretation of the bible?

    I wouldn't and I would not want HER teaching history either.

    39 years teaching?

    Time for the old mare to be put out to pasture.

  • LRDawg
    April 12, 2019 at 5:04 p.m.

    I commend the NATIONAL SOCIAL STUDIES TEACHER OF THE YEAR, Vicki Gonterman. Pretty sure she didn't receive that achievement because she doesn't teach children what they need to be taught. History makes racists feel small....after that WHIPPIN' the UNION (U.S.) put on the Confederacy (TRAITOR's of U.S.) their way of life was FORCED to change. Surrender and cowardice has no place in the home of the BRAVE....glad Mrs. Gonterman tells it like is

    April 12, 2019 at 6:30 p.m.

    Perhaps the top star needs to be changed to represent Political Correctness (aka: denial of reality). It doesn't matter how 'wrong' the south may gave been in the War of Northern Aggression - it happened. The star recognizes a part of Arkansas' history and the family members who died. The star does not indicate that slavery was the right thing to do. Most of those who fought for the South did not own slaves. But they did believe in states' rights and fought against the effort of the federal government to force states to do things that should have been up to the states to decide. We still have that problem today in some areas.
    The war is long over. Slavery is long illegal. Learn about it so that we don't repeat it -- then get a life and move along.