Today's Paper Search Latest New app In the news Traffic #Gazette200 Paper Trails Listen Digital replica FAQ Weather Newsletters Obits Puzzles + Games Archive

Gov. Asa Hutchinson will consider the immediately ensuing paragraph an absurd outrage. But it's instead a rich irony. It sounds inherently contradictory but is true.

Here it is: The greatest stain on Hutchinson's otherwise solid governorship--partisanship and ideology aside--is the decline of health insurance for the neediest Arkansans.

For the governor and his intimates, the situation seems totally to the contrary: Hutchinson took office as a Republican dealing with a Republican Legislature intensely averse to the Affordable Care Act and its Medicaid expansion, and, against those odds, managed bravely and deftly to save Medicaid expansion for somewhere in the vicinity of a quarter-million of the state's poorest residents.

The recent eviction of 18,000 persons from those rolls, the governor and his people will argue, resulted from a work requirement that was essential to securing the aforementioned Republican legislative acquiescence. They will explain that those 18,000 were removed only after arduous efforts to locate them by the state Human Services Department and independent service agencies on which the department prevailed for help.

Hutchinson and his administration want absolution for throwing 18,000 people off health insurance because they managed to save health insurance for more than 10 times that many.

But human services for the needy are not designed on a basis by which you can take credit for broader compassion as an offset for narrower meanness.

The fact remains that this administration is throwing people off Medicaid expansion in a way that has been declared illegal by a federal court in Washington, D.C., and which has emerged as the national example of how not to do a work requirement, if indeed a state must do one at all, which several of the red ones in the Trump Meanness Era seem to think they do.

In Indiana, officials are touting their new work requirement as nothing like the vanguard disaster in Arkansas, though detractors think it looks all too similar.

Hutchinson defends his work-requirement program as (1) necessary politically to save Medicaid expansion, and (2) a process that was steadily improved from the initial computer-click complexity, and (3) a worthy inventory by discovering 18,000 people who can't be accounted for, thus saving the state the monthly private premiums for those persons under the innovative "private option" form of Medicaid expansion that buys private insurance for enrollees.

Alas, there is a simple and compelling counter to each: (1) Health insurance for poor people is entirely too vital to be subjected to use as a political tool. (2) While the state did endeavor to make its work-reporting requirement less of an obstacle course for poor people, the repeated changes in reporting methods served mainly to enhance the confusion. (3) A true inventory of recipients--and a cessation of premium payments for recipients who can't be found--would be wise. But it should not be disguised as a punitive work requirement. And it should not kick people off and require re-application but simply suspend payment of premiums subject to restarting premiums and paying them retroactively for missing persons showing up, at, say, an emergency room.

Meantime, Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families issued a report last week showing a recent enrollment decline, after years of growth, in probably the state's finest program--ARKids First, meaning health insurance for needy children, whether abjectly poor or in the low-income working class.

The report blames the state less than federal anti-immigrant policies under the Trump administration. But it does make two recommendations that would reduce the onerous restrictiveness of existing state policies and practices.

It asked the state to stop the absurdly mean-spirited practice of refusing to pay for outreach programs to spread the news to the poor of the availability of health insurance.

Just think about that: It is the policy of state government--in language written into the appropriation--not to tell poor people about how they might get health insurance.

And Arkansas Advocates asked the state to stop reassessing ARKids Part A insurance for the poorest kids randomly at any point, and to do so once annually, as is the case in Part B for higher-income families.

The working poor's income is typically volatile--by season, month or even week.

Yet the state reserves the right to come along in, say, July, and say, "Too bad, little guy, your daddy shouldn't have mowed that extra yard last month."

One check, once a year, on annualized income--that's the way to go if your objective is service, not punishment.

Those policies pre-date Hutchinson's governorship. Arkansas has been mean-spirited to its poor for far longer than Hutchinson has been governor.

But now an opportunity presents itself to the Hutchinson administration to repair some of the health-care meanness for which rich irony is specifically and not inappropriately besmirching it.

Outreach programs and annualized income-eligibility checks--those would make Hutchinson's legacy even better.

John Brummett, whose column appears regularly in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, is a member of the Arkansas Writers' Hall of Fame. Email him at Read his @johnbrummett Twitter feed.

Web only on 07/03/2019

Print Headline: BRUMMETT ONLINE: Asa can improve legacy


Sponsor Content

You must be signed in to post comments


  • RBolt
    July 3, 2019 at 8:28 a.m.

    The Republicans were very effective at achieving their usual goal of punishing the poor in order to benefit the wealthy and powerful. This issue is a win for them, especially if others quit whining about basic human values. Heck, they are even making progress at undermining health insurance availability for our neediest children. Now if only more of these impoverished losers will just quickly and quietly die, we can only imagine how many more taxes we could cut for the wealthy.

  • GeneralMac
    July 3, 2019 at 8:39 a.m.

    ." a punitive work requirement "

    What a play on words !

    Nowhere in this column did I see..." young, able bodied people with no dependents"

    John Brummett always was "the master" at twisting facts by means of omission.

  • limb
    July 3, 2019 at 8:43 a.m.

    RB, perfect post!

  • GeneralMac
    July 3, 2019 at 8:50 a.m.

    Many of our ancestors benefitted from FDR's help in the late 30's during the depression.

    WPA and CCC were great programs that people wanting to get GOVT benefits had to WORK.

    Today, John Brummett CALLS "WORK REQUIREMENTS"..."punitive" .. and his hench men "usual suspects" applaud.

  • GOHOGS19
    July 3, 2019 at 9 a.m.

    unbelievable that some think we should give handouts to those who can work but refuse to do so

  • GeneralMac
    July 3, 2019 at 9:30 a.m.

    "some think that we should give hand outs to those who can work but refuse to do so
    ( key words).."can work"..."refuse "

    Yes indeed !

    BOLTAR,LMB, John Brummett , and other "usual suspects"

  • limb
    July 3, 2019 at 10:36 a.m.

    You pay more for uninsured at the ER than the cost for expanded Medicaid. If party of Trump wants to pay MORE for uninsured then that is what makes sense to them.

  • mrcharles
    July 3, 2019 at 10:53 a.m.

    gop ILKS are just trying to take care of the congested highways. Too many people driving to sport bars to see our Women soccer team beating other nations [ go USA!] .

    And after all , Jesus said , go buy you a sword [ machine gun in todays parlance] not help out the poor [ or did he?], and if arkansas once again decides to succeed from merica and its old glory flag [ just dont kneel before it like some altar of Baal] and joyfully kill USA soldiers flying old glory [ hey, arkansas got a star and bars flag , dont need no stinkin USA flag-yes, no,yes, no-- these ilks get confused of how special that flag is] .

    Besides health of arkansans is not like how important it is to put up monuments on public grounds or to take federal dollars greater than we pay in, cause we of course got southern in our blood...

    rb, remember the great godnod MM [ an ADG typical editor type] just cant get too concerned with children, but hog poop, he is right on that. oh , and I forgot them there children are now breathing so they have lost their glitter of being used by the celestial decoders way of life which includes multi-million dollar jets to do the work of the lord.

    Damn , all this politics is just to complicated.

    I read somewhere we dont need health care as you can just ask for intercessory prayer to get well or move mountains or ask your favorite team to mercy rule the other team of heathens.

  • adrink
    July 3, 2019 at 11 a.m.

    Good work Governor Hutchinson! Brummett failed to mention young and able bodied. As usual Brummett is a propagandist instead of an editorialist. A half truth is no truth at all!!!!