Today's Paper Search Latest In the news Traffic #Gazette200 Drivetime Mahatma Listen Digital replica FAQ Weather Newsletters Obits Puzzles + Games Archive

What did you think of that bunch of socialists you just saw debating onstage?

Wait, you may protest, you didn't see any socialists up there. And you'd be right. The Democratic Party has clearly moved left in recent years, but none of the presidential candidates are anything close to being actual socialists--not even Bernie Sanders, whose embrace of the label is really more about branding ("I'm anti-establishment!") than substance.

Nobody in these debates wants government ownership of the means of production, which is what socialism used to mean. Most of the candidates are instead what Europeans would call social democrats: advocates of a private-sector-driven economy, but with a stronger social safety net, enhanced bargaining power for workers, and tighter regulation of corporate malfeasance. They want America to be more like Denmark, not more like Venezuela.

Leading Republicans, however, routinely describe Democrats, even those on the right of their party, as socialists. Indeed, all indications are that denunciations of Democrats' "socialist" agenda will be front and center in the general election campaign. And everyone in the news media accepts this as the normal state of affairs.

Which goes to show the extent to which Republican extremism has been accepted simply as a fact of life, barely worth mentioning.

To see what I mean, imagine the media firestorm, the screams about lost civility, we'd experience if any prominent Democrat described Republicans as a party of fascists, let alone if Democrats made that claim the centerpiece of their national campaign. And such an accusation would be somewhat over the top--but it would be a lot closer to the truth than calling Democrats socialists.

The other day The New York Times published an op-ed that used analysis of party platforms to place U.S. political parties on a left-right spectrum along with their counterparts abroad. The study found that the Republican Party is far to the right of mainstream European conservative parties. It's even to the right of anti-immigrant parties like Britain's UKIP and France's National Rally. If we saw something like America's Republicans in another country, we'd classify them as white nationalist extremists.

True, this is just one study. But it matches up with lots of other evidence. Political scientists who use congressional votes to track ideology find that Republicans have moved drastically to the right over the past four decades, to the point where they are now more conservative than they were at the height of the Gilded Age.

Compare the Republicans, point by point, with parties almost everyone would classify as right-wing authoritarians like Hungary's Fidesz, which has preserved some of the forms of democracy but has effectively created a permanent one-party state.

Fidesz has cemented its power by politicizing the judiciary, creating rigged election rules, suppressing opposition media and using the power of the state to reward the party's cronies while punishing businesses that don't toe the line. Does any of this sound like something that can't happen here? In fact, does any of it sound like something that isn't already happening here, and which Republicans will do much more of if they get the chance?

One might even argue that the GOP stands out among the West's white nationalist parties for its exceptional willingness to crash right through the guardrails of democracy. Extreme gerrymandering, naked voter suppression and stripping power from offices the other party manages to win all the same--these practices seem more prevalent here than in the failing democracies of Eastern Europe.

And isn't it remarkable how blase we've become about threats of legal persecution and/or physical violence against anyone who criticizes a Republican president?

So it's really something to see Republicans trying to tar Democrats as un-American socialists. If they want to see a party that really has broken with fundamental American values, they should look in the mirror.

But that won't happen, of course. Whoever the Democrats nominate--even if it's Joe Biden--Republicans will paint him or her as the second coming of Hugo Chávez. The only question is whether it will work.

It might not, or at least not as well as in the past. By spending decades calling everything that might improve Americans' lives "socialist," Republicans have squandered much of the accusation's force. And Donald Trump, who was installed in office with Russian help and clearly prefers foreign dictators to democratic allies, is probably less able to play the "Democrats are unpatriotic" card than previous Republican presidents.

Still, a lot will depend on how the news media handle dishonest attacks. Will we keep seeing headlines that repeat false claims ("Trump Says Democrats Will Ban Hamburgers"), with the information that the claim is false buried deep inside the article? Will we get coverage of actual policy proposals, as opposed to horse-race analysis that only asks how those proposals seem to be playing?

I guess we'll soon find out.


Paul Krugman, who won the 2008 Nobel Prize in economics, writes for the New York Times.

Editorial on 06/29/2019

Print Headline: The extreme party


Sponsor Content

You must be signed in to post comments


  • BoudinMan
    June 29, 2019 at 8:32 a.m.

    No, Krugman, most sane, rational clear-thinking American voters know exactly how extreme this repug party is. And, I believe you misspelled "hamberders."

  • 0boxerssuddenlinknet
    June 29, 2019 at 4:30 p.m.

    I don't care what anybody calls the crazy democrat party that has moved so far left middle Americans can not recognize their old party. after watching the two debates this week i can see why the DEMs are worried about the 2020 election, they know there was no one on either stage that could help stimulate the American economy reduce unemployment. strengthen our military and negotiate tariffs with China and other world economies.EXTREME ? you have got to be kidding ? as a conservative American i do not want open borders I do not want my tax dollars providing free medical to every tom dick and illegal harry that comes slinking over our borders. I don't want China stealing our intellectual property. and as most Americans I am disgusted with other Americans who do not want to work for the better things in life but expect to be given things they have not earned. sorry if that scares the dems into believing i'm a nazi. boo !

  • Illinoisroy
    June 29, 2019 at 5:36 p.m.

    Article is accurate and to the point. Headline isn't so much, most reasonable/rational Americans can see the insanity within the republican party.