NEW YORK -- Federal antitrust regulators say a proposed merger of the old-school shaving company Schick and the upstart Harry's would end up costing consumers.
The Federal Trade Commission on Monday sued to block Edgewell Personal Care Co.'s $1.37 billion acquisition of Harry's, which was supposed to be finalized this year. The FTC argues that bringing two major shaving brands together would hurt competition.
"Harry's is a uniquely disruptive competitor in the wet shave market, and it has forced its rivals to offer lower prices, and more options, to consumers across the country," Daniel Francis, a deputy director in the agency's competition bureau, said in a statement. "Edgewell's effort to short-circuit competition by buying up its newer rival promises serious harm to consumers."
Edgewell's Schick is the No. 2 razor-maker in the U.S., behind Gillette. Both brands were forced to slash prices and overhaul their marketing strategies in recent years in response to the rise of Harry's and rival Dollar Shave Club, which both started as direct-to-consumer digital brands.
"The loss of Harry's as an independent competitor would remove a critical disruptive rival that has driven down prices and spurred innovation in an industry that was previously dominated by two main suppliers, one of whom is the acquirer," the FTC said.
New York-based Harry's, which has expanded to sell its products at Target and Walmart, had hoped to capitalize on Edgewell's large distribution channels and Schick's blade technology. Edgewell, which has struggled to turn around Schick's slumping sales, had hoped to leverage Harry's direct-to-consumer marketing base and digital savvy.
Harry's co-founders Jeff Raider and Andy Katz-Mayfield said Monday that they were disappointed by the lawsuit and would evaluate their next steps.
"We believe strongly that the combined company will deliver exceptional brands and products at a great value," Raider and Katz-Mayfield said in a joint statement.
Edgewell Chief Executive Officer Rod Little said his company would respond to the lawsuit "in due course."
Raider and Katz-Mayfield, who would become co-presidents of Edgewell's U.S. operations under the deal, have said Harry's would remain a distinct brand after the merger, including sticking with its competitive pricing.
But the acquisition had raised questions among Wall Street analysts about how two competing shaving brands would exist under the same parent company without harming each other.
Shares of Edgewell rose 13% in afternoon trading Monday. The company, based in Shelton, Conn., also owns the Banana Boat, Hawaiian Tropic, Playtex and Carefree brands.
Other major consumer goods companies have bought up trendy shaving newcomers in recent years.
Unilever bought Dollar Shave Club for $1 billion in 2016. Unlike Edgewell, however, Unilever did not previously have a major shaving brand. In 2018, Gillette owner Procter & Gamble Co. bought Tristan Walker, owner of Bevel, a shaving and skin-care brand aimed at black men. Bevel, however, makes a double-edged safety razor that is a niche in the shaving industry.
The FTC said Edgewell and Procter & Gamble for years operated their respective Schick and Gillette brands of men's razors as a "comfortable duopoly" with annual price increases not driven by changes in costs or demand. As a result of Harry's entering the market, Procter & Gamble and Edgewell were forced to reduce prices and develop new products.
Information for this article was contributed by Alexandra Olson of The Associated Press and by David McLaughlin and Gerald Porter Jr. of Bloomberg News.
Business on 02/04/2020
Print Headline: Shaving firms' merger opposed