Today's Paper Latest After 9/11 Coronavirus iPad Core Values Weather The Article Story ideas Newsletters Obits Puzzles Archive

In bad faith?

Korean sect’s methods scrutinized amid pandemic by CHOE SANG-HUN THE NEW YORK TIMES | March 14, 2020 at 2:41 a.m.
Lee Ho-yeon attends a service at a Presbyterian church in Guri, South Korea, on Sunday. Lee left the Shincheonji Church of Jesus in 2015. (The New York Times/Woohae Cho)

SEOUL, South Korea -- More than 1.2 million citizens have called for the secretive church to be disbanded. One province asked the public to report church members to a hotline for coronavirus testing. Smartphone apps help identify the church's 1,100 once-obscure facilities in South Korea, most already plastered with "off-limits" signs by disease-control officials.

Even before the coronavirus scourge, South Korea's Shincheonji Church of Jesus had faced increased suspicion over its tactics to attract tens of thousands of recruits. But in the month since the church was identified as the epicenter of infections in the country, it has become the target of scorn, vilification and open hatred.

The founder, Lee Man-hee, 88, who has promised its 240,000 members entry to the "new heaven and new earth," is now the potential subject of a prosecutor investigation into possible murder charges.

Parents of recruits accuse him of "brainwashed slavery." Former members describe him as another in a long line of spiritual snake-oil salesmen in South Korea, a fertile ground for untraditional religious sects.

[CORONAVIRUS: Click here for our complete coverage »]

A large majority of the country's more than 7,500 coronavirus patients are Shincheonji members in Daegu, a city in the southeast, or people who had come into contact with them. An additional cluster of cases has emerged in Cheongdo, a county near Daegu that is Lee's birthplace and a regular pilgrimage destination for his followers.


The church has protested what it called "scapegoating" by South Koreans eager to discredit what had been the fastest-growing religious sect in the country, as other big churches worry about declining membership.

"The entire society has gone berserk against our church since the virus outbreak," said Lee Young-Soo, 54, a Shincheonji member whose sister, a fellow church member, died after having fallen from her seventh-floor apartment in the southern city of Ulsan last month. She said her sister had confided that her husband's long-running abuse over her church had intensified after the virus outbreak.

Another Shincheonji member who church officials said had suffered spousal abuse, a 42-year-old mother of two, died after having fallen from her 11th-floor apartment Monday night. Police are investigating both cases.

"The society is so wrong, and I am so saddened," Lee Young-Soo said.

Still, the church is inextricably linked to the spread of the affliction in South Korea, one of the largest outbreaks outside China.

The church's clandestine nature is part of what made it a focal point for the country's anger and fear. Officials have struggled to find and screen church members for the virus.

Kwon Jun-Wook, a senior disease-control official, said last month that when officials had tried to reach church members, they found many incommunicado. Daegu's mayor said Tuesday that dozens of Shincheonji members must be immediately tested for the coronavirus or face fines. The city of Seoul has accused Lee and his disciples of failing to provide full membership lists.

"Lee Man-hee is a psychopath who has lied and lied until he believed his own lie that he was the true messiah," said Jeong Ji-su, a former disciple who left in July.


Lee is far from the first person claiming to be a messiah in South Korea.

Shamanism -- worshipping a multitude of deities including dead parents, ancient warriors and mountain spirits -- has infused society for millenniums, interacting with new arrivals like Christianity and making some Koreans amenable to embracing new belief systems, said Koo Se-woong, a scholar who has researched Korean religions.

"Promising a new world and a 'New Jerusalem' in Korea is nothing new among Christian churches in South Korea," Koo said.

As the country has suffered war and deprivation in the past century, 120 self-styled messiahs promising a new world of peace have emerged, 70 commanding sizable followings. The best known is the Rev. Sun Myung Moon, founder of the Unification Church, who died in 2012.

Some ended up in jail on fraud or rape charges or lived in disgrace after the rapture they had promised never came. But their apostles split and spread, rebranding themselves into new sects. Lee was one of them.

On the day she first encountered the church in September 2016, Jeong, 25, recalled in an interview, she had been hurrying through a Seoul subway station. Two friendly looking women and a young man about her age asked if she could spare a few minutes to give feedback on a movie script.

They entered a fast-food restaurant, where her initiation began. She became a full member in July 2017. Jeong said she had been brainwashed and spent the next two years recruiting fellow young people just as she had been.


Shincheonji recruiters seek converts who might be vulnerable, first uncovering personal problems, like low self-esteem in Jeong's case. They offer counseling, building friendship and persuading recruits that Bible studies can help, former members said.

"The entire church was a con job," Jeong said. "When they targeted you for proselytizing, everyone who approached you in the cloak of chance encounter was a member of Shincheonji -- only that you didn't know it."

Other former members report proselytizers approached with free tarot card readings, personality tests and foreign-language classes.

"Young people are attracted to Shincheonji at times like this when opportunities dwindle because the church raises hopes of jobs as pastors and preachers and promises a spiritually fulfilling life, even promising eternal life and high priestship when the new world comes," said Kim Seong-Ja, 58, a former member.

Young converts often lived together in cheap crowded rooms, former members said. Dating, or any distraction from the goal of winning converts, was discouraged.

"We were nothing but proselytizing robots," said Lee Ho-yeon, 24, a former member. "I spent as little as possible on food and used what little money I left in my pocket to buy Starbucks coffee for people I wanted to convert."

Because of Shincheonji's suspect image, proselytizers would delay revealing their affiliation until confident that their recruits were ready, former members said.

Once they ​passed written tests after months of Bible studies, converts ​became participants in a spectacular commencement ceremony. Life as a church member included meetings, proselytizing missions on the streets and daily progress reports on how many people they had tried to recruit and how their recruits were doing in Bible studies, former members said.

"They said it was OK to lie to our parents, as it was OK for moms to call bitter medicine a chocolate when feeding it to a sick baby," said Stella Seo, 29, who was in Shincheonji for seven years until late 2018.


The practice of disavowing membership carried over to how at least some church members responded to the coronavirus outbreak. South Koreans were outraged when it was revealed last month that church members had received a message telling them to deny their affiliation with Shincheonji and to keep proselytizing even after the outbreak was reported among its congregation.

Shincheonji said that the instruction was not church policy and that it had punished the official who issued it.

While Shincheonji's recruitment methods have drawn recent condemnation for helping spread the virus, its approach has long galled more mainstream churches, which have accused it of sending undercover proselytizers, known as harvesters, into their congregations and stealing members.

Sometimes, the harvesters were accused of sowing internal discord in a church and taking it over, a feat celebrated as "moving a mountain" among Shincheonji members.

Shincheonji said that disgruntled former members and traditional churches alarmed over their shrinking congregations had spread false rumors to discredit the church.

But in video footage of internal lecturing viewed by The New York Times, a proselytizing instructor said the old way of founding a church and then building a congregation "is too expensive, takes too much manpower and is too time-consuming."

"It's better to swallow existing churches," she said to a chorus of amens. "But you must keep this strategy to yourself."

Lee Man-hee has defended the church's response to the outbreak, and Shincheonji has issued statements through a spokesman repeating that the church was cooperating with the government and demanding an end to "scapegoating."

Eo Kwang-il, 38, a Shincheonji member, said that because of overwhelming bias against their church, members hid their affiliation and used ruses to win converts. But he said the church never forced members to abandon school or jobs for the sake of proselytizing.


How the church conducts gatherings, however, has drawn scrutiny as a spreader of the disease. Worshippers sit packed tightly on the floor and attend even when sick, former members say.

"We were taught not to be afraid of illness," said Lee Ho-yeon, who left the church in 2015. A church leader told followers Feb. 9 that although hundreds of people had died in Wuhan, China, where the outbreak began, no Shincheonji worshippers there became sick, according to the audio file of the sermon released by Yoon Jae-Deok, an expert on religious groups like Shincheonji.

The government has repeatedly warned that the battle against the coronavirus depends on how quickly infected church members can be isolated. Lee has urged them to "follow the government's instructions," avoid gatherings and proselytize only online.

Some parents, like Choi Mi-sook, 56, mother of Shincheonji member Kim Yoo-jeong, 25, remain distraught.

"I don't even know where she lives, whether she is tested for the coronavirus, whether she is well or even alive," the mother said.

At her home in Goyang, South Korea, on March 7, Doo Song-ja weeps while talking about her daughter, whom she tried and failed to persuade to leave the Shincheonji Church of Jesus. (The New York Times/Woohae Cho)

Religion on 03/14/2020

Print Headline: In bad faith?


Sponsor Content