Subscribe Register Login

Tuesday, July 29, 2014, 4:19 p.m.
Top Picks - Capture Arkansas

Government can be liable for flood, U.S. high court rules

By The Associated Press

This article was originally published December 4, 2012 at 10:13 a.m. Updated December 4, 2012 at 10:34 a.m.

— The Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that the federal government is not automatically exempt from paying for damage caused by temporary flooding from government-owned dams.

In an 8-0 decision, the court sided with the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission in its appeal of a lower court ruling that said the federal government did not have to pay for damage to thousands of trees after the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers released more water than usual from its dam on the Black River. The release of additional water benefited farmers, but the commission said its hardwood forest suffered significant damage.

The commission said the damage amounted to the government taking its property, for which compensation would be owed under the Constitution.

The Court of Federal Claims agreed and ordered the government to pay $5.6 million for destroyed and damaged trees.

But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington said damage resulting from temporary, as opposed to permanent or inevitable, flooding cannot be compensated under the Constitution’s Takings Clause.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, writing for the court, said the appeals court was mistaken. Ginsburg said that “government-induced flooding of limited duration, but severe impact, can amount to a taking of property warranting just compensation.”

But Ginsburg also cautioned that the court was not deciding that the government has to pay for all flooding caused by government action, or even necessarily in this case. Instead, courts must consider the details on a case-by-case basis.

The justices also ordered the appeals court to consider other arguments advanced by the government to avoid liability.

Justice Elena Kagan sat out the case because she worked on it while serving in the Justice Department.

The case is Arkansas Game and Fish Commission v. U.S., 11-597.

Comments on: Government can be liable for flood, U.S. high court rules

To report abuse or misuse of this area please hit the "Suggest Removal" link in the comment to alert our online managers. Read our Terms of Use policy.

Subscribe Register Login

You must login to make comments.

Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 total comments

Sandborn says... December 4, 2012 at 1:26 p.m.

Only one problem...the government will have countless experts to counter argue everything.

( | suggest removal )

Jjackk says... December 4, 2012 at 10:39 p.m.

Shipping and farmers have been demanding more water for a month now. Let them pay for the poor trees.

( | suggest removal )

  • page
  • 1
Click here to make a comment

To report abuse or misuse of this area please hit the "Suggest Removal" link in the comment to alert our online managers. Read our Terms of Use policy.

TOP JOBS

  • Direct care positi

    timber ridgeons Benton, ARProvide support to individuals, in...
    BENTON, AR

  • Ur specialist super.

    UR Specialist Supervisor Immediate OpeningFull-time: 8am-5pm...
    LITTLE ROCK, AR

  • Warehouse clerk- for lighting

    maintenance company Monday thru Friday, early morning hours...
    LITTLE ROCK, AR

  • Library assistant

    library assistant ii-Youth ProgrammerFull-time public servic...
    LITTLE ROCK, AR

  • Dental assistant

    dental hygienist in Dr. Kevin Jones WLR office, 2 days a wee...
    LITTLE ROCK, AR

Search 892 jobs >

Top Picks - Capture Arkansas
Arkansas Online